| Nevada Inventors Association P O. Box 9905 Reno, NV 89507-0905 Phone (775) 322-9636 Fax (775) 322-0147 http://www.nevadainventors.org Email address: costar@attglobal.net |
![]() |
Dear John,
Your wife called this afternoon asking for some help in getting
protection for your roof truss idea. This letter is in response to that.
When you have an idea that appears to be marketable, you should reduce it to a description and sketch, called an Invention Disclosure Document. sample enclosed for guide)
Then as soon as you can, have a witness sign and date it under the
phrase "read and understood by" ********* ******on this ****** day of
*******, 2005 You must also sign and date it of course, (as inventor)
with legible name, address and phone number. Also include the address
and phone number of the witness. Everything must be legible, with the
names printed below the signatures. A notary won't help because they
cannot testify to the content of a document. It's also a stranger to
whom you are revealing your idea -- an unnecessary risk.
This witness should be someone who is a friend, who will not benefit by
the success of your product, is not a relative, and who would be willing
to go to civil court and say "yes, that is my signature and that is the
day I signed it, and yes, I understood what I was signing, because Joe
Inventor explained it to me". Their only motive should be to help you
establish a date of disclosure and nothing else. The idea is a reliable
witness for an important date. Forget about mailing a certified letter
to yourself. It's not reliable in court because the chances of getting
someone from the Postal Service to corroborate that document by
testimony is just about zip.
Since June 8th, 1995 there has been available a new category of patent
application called the "Provisional Patent Application." It's purpose is
to establish an application date that is in effect for up to one year
before a complete non-provisional application is filed with the U.S.
Patent and Trademark Office. (PTO) It currently costs $100.00 to file,
offers no protection, and is only a means of establishing a date that
may be relied upon for an early application date, but only if no new
material is added to the final application. It does offer a legal
"Patent Pending" status though, if immediate litigation, licensing or
marketing is critical.
Under current U.S. patent law, the inventor who is "First to Invent",
with a solid paper trail, is awarded the patent as the "true inventor."
The Provisional Patent Application is only one step in that paper trail
until, and if, the law is ever changed to "First to File."
After you have established a date of invention, with your confidential
disclosure document, the law then says that you must diligently pursue
it to filing a complete and accepted patent application. That's called
"Reduction to Practice." You can take as long as necessary to do this if
you make entries in a log book, or journal, or diary or whatever, as
long as it is a bound book of some sort. Bookkeeper's ledger books that
have numbered pages are OK, but an inventors' logbook is best. (see
www.ipbookstore.com on last page)
Your logbook entries should be every time you make a significant change
in your invention, or every time you have a relevant piece of evidence
of progress, such as a phone bill, a freight bill, an invoice for a
purchase, a quotation letter etc. Anything that has a date on it to show
that you're diligently pursuing its development to the point of Patent
Application. Just make a note in your record explaining each document
that you attach to that page.
You haven't waited too long to start your book. You can start anytime by
just entering a history of what you have done to date. Start by saying:
My invention, which I call the "Vegas Roof Truss" (or whatever) was
conceived by me on ____, 2004 (or whenever) and I refined the concept
and reduced it to writing and sketch form so I could have it witnessed
on ____, 2005 (or whenever). I then. . . . . (get the picture?) Just a
narrative history of what you have done that shows you have progressed
to this date. Fill in the dates as near as you can remember. Be sure and
make a few sketches that show any changes, or improvements, if that is
true. Photos showing prototype improvements are a good idea. I know this
is asking a lot, but you need good documentation or you might wish you
had if you're ever in court. Then it will be too late. It's simply
developing good record keeping habits.
Now, after you have brought this introduction up to date, (this is the
important part) sign and date it, and have a witness sign and date it.
(Perhaps the same witness who signed your disclosure.) Then every time
you make another entry have it witnessed again, on the same page that
you sign. Fill in blank areas with diagonal lines so that there are no
spaces where one can say you made the entry after it was signed. If you
leave a page blank, write on it "blank page."
All this is for a reason: it is leading up to the day you receive a
receipt from the Patent and Trademark Office that your application has
been received and file numbered. From then on that date is carved in
stone. And you will have an ironclad paper trail from the date of invention.
I would suggest that you make an entry in your book at least once every
couple of months. Don't let it appear that your project was ever abandoned.
Your wife said that you may be selling this product soon. That's OK, as
long as you keep records. The only thing is, when you offer a product to
the public, either by marketing it or offering it for sale, your One
Year Time Clock starts. If you haven't applied for a patent within that
year it will become public domain.
Now, your next step after starting the journal is to do a "preliminary
patent search." You can do it yourself online or here at the UNR library
in Reno, but to go 450 miles from Las Vegas to here and pay 2 or 3 days
expenses is going to be more expensive than having a professional
searcher do it. Their fees run about $250 to $400, and their search may
take a week or more.
Because Vegas doesn't have a patent depository library like Reno, your
best bet is probably to do an online search or look up a patent search
firm and contact them to find out what their fees are. The best search I
believe, is the one done by the inventor himself, because he knows his
product better than he can communicate it to someone else.
If you do decide to have the search done by someone else, I recommend
Ms. Usha Mehta, who is a local Reno searcher.
Her E-mail address is UMEHTA4PS@aol.com Her phone number is 329-2032
Searches may seem expensive at first, but if you can't do your own for
some reason they really aren't. The couple hundred dollars you spend is
part of the inventing process. Inventing is not cheap. You will have to
cough up over $1,200 for just patent fees alone to the patent office.
($550 to file, and $700 to issue) It's exorbitant, but with present PTO
administration's policies it is a fact. There's also maintenance fees at
3 1/2, 7 1/2 and 11 1/2 years.
There are always the "idea promotion" scams that can be found in the
back of magazines, Radio, and on TV. (800 numbers) They promise
marketing "ideas" but it can easily cost you from $8,000 to $12,000 and
all you'll get is ripped off.
John, I highly recommend that you purchase the book "Patent It Yourself"
by David Pressman, latest edition is the tenth. Here in Reno, the
Sundance Bookstore on Fourth St, west of Keystone usually stocks it.
It's not cheap, it sells for around $50.00 but it's an excellent
investment for any serious inventor. You will learn a hell of a lot
about patent writing by using that book. In case you can not find it,
the publisher is NOLO Press, 950 Parker Street, Berkeley, CA 94710.
Order it online at a discount at http://www.nolo.com or call
1-800-728-3555, to order by phone.
You can file your own Patent Application by using that book as a guide
plus the form and text of a similar patent you obtain as a result of
your search. You just substitute your words for theirs. It's not
plagiarism because government paper is not copyrighted. It's ethical and
legal.
But for a first time I recommend you use a patent attorney (Ian Burns
comes to mind) for as much of the work that you can afford, like writing
the legal "claims." It shouldn't take him more than two or three hours,
and if his fees are around $300 per hour, or so, you have to consider
that. But a word of caution -- make sure you discuss it with the lawyer
first. Ask him if he will do it, and ask what he estimates his time will
be and how much will it cost. If he gets offended, or won't work on that
basis, forget it. Find another one. One last word about patent
attorneys: they usually charge from $3,500 to "whatever" to write an
application from scratch. Naturally it depends on the attorney and on
the complexity of the device to be covered, but you will get a better
patent application, obviously. Drawing fees, as a rule, are extra. NOLO
Press also has an excellent book on doing your own patent drawings. The
patent office will accept drawings from a printer or a copier because
they are in permanent form. They may insist however on submission of
drawings on 67 lb. "Bristol" paper so it will stand up in the file. With
electronic filing, which the PTO encourages, that is not necessary.
It also greatly depends on the amount of work the inventor is willing to
do by himself. If you hire your own searcher, for example, you might
spend $250. If you tell an attorney to do it, figure another $250 at
least for him to have the same guy do the same work. (get the picture ?)
Don't ever be afraid to ask how much is it going to cost you. (after he
sees what is involved, of course) But remember this: Whatever you hire
someone else to do for you, is something you will never learn to do for
yourself. When I first got into it I didn't know my butt from my
shoulder about any of it. Fortunately I didn't fall into the "product
development scam" trap. I bought Pressman's book instead. Now I have
written two patent applications by myself and received what I believe to
be two good patents because of it.
Beginning in 2003 there are software available to inventors for writing
patent applications. This is great news for inventors who do not have
the funds to hire an attorney at all. The names of the software are
"Patent Wizard" for provisional applications, plus "PatentEase" and
"PatentPro" for complete applications. Current costs are around $300 to
$350, with the provisional application software about $200. Discounts
are available by ordering from the "Inventors' Digest" magazine. (see
end of letter for URL's)
I do feel that you should establish early on a trade name, logo, or
product name and establish a Trademark. It doesn't cost anything to put
a superscript "TM" behind your logo or product name. That's a notice to
the world that you intend to register it. Once you register it with the
PTO you can then place the R in a circle after your logo. Currently it
will cost $335, but you can't do it anyway until you've marketed the
product in interstate commerce.
If at all possible, a prototype that works is a must! Not because anyone
requires it, but to prove to yourself it works, plus as you are making
the prototype you'll be amazed at how many ideas you get about making it
simpler, or better, or different. I'm assuming you aren't reinventing a
diesel engine or locomotive, of course.
Keep in mind that if you are employed, and do any work on your
prototype, drawings or notebook at your place of work, or use any of
your employer's tools, resources or time, you probably will be obligated
legally to turn over the title of your patent to your employer. I'm not
aware of any legal precedent that would be a guideline for what belongs
to an employer and what belongs to an employee in the absence of a
contract, but common sense dictates that if you invent something
relevant to your employer's business, then he could logically claim you
learned the technology on his time and with his facilities.
It would seem that there are obvious elements in an employment
relationship that would determine who owns what, but in the event of a
potential lawsuit it would be wise to approach your employer early on
and establish what you can and cannot patent on your own. Sometimes an
offer to share licensing royalties if the employer pays the fees and
costs would be the best course to follow.
That's about all I can think of for now. Good Luck!! Make a mint!